Cheesy Chicken Stuffed Peppers

My neighbor knocked on my door one Thursday evening with a bag of bell peppers from her garden, and I had exactly the kind of leftover rotisserie chicken in my fridge that felt like a sign. Within an hour, four peppers were baking and filling the kitchen with this incredible savory aroma that had my kids hovering near the oven before they were even done. That night taught me that the best dinners aren't always the ones you plan—sometimes they're the ones that come together from what you have on hand, transforming ordinary ingredients into something that tastes like you've been cooking all day.

I made these for my book club last month, and watching three people go back for seconds while barely pausing their conversation felt like the highest compliment I could get. Someone asked if I'd made everything from scratch, and I laughed—rotisserie chicken at its finest. That moment crystallized why I keep coming back to this recipe: it tastes homemade and intentional, but it never asks more of you than you're willing to give.

Ingredients

• Bell peppers (4 large, any color): The whole structure of the dish, so pick ones that feel sturdy and have flat bottoms so they'll sit upright without rolling around in the baking dish.
• Cooked chicken (2 cups, shredded): Rotisserie is your time-saver here—just shred it right off the bone, and it's already seasoned in a way that plays nicely with the other flavors.
• Cooked rice (1 cup): White or brown both work; I tend toward brown for texture, but honestly use whatever you've got.
• Cheddar cheese (1 1/2 cups, shredded, divided): The sharpness cuts through the richness of the cream cheese and keeps the filling from tasting one-note.
• Cream cheese (1/4 cup, softened): This is the secret—it acts like a binder and adds a subtle tang that brings everything together instead of letting the filling feel like separate components.
• Onion (1 small, finely chopped) and garlic (2 cloves, minced): A quick sauté mellows them so they add flavor depth without the sharp bite of raw alliums.
• Diced tomatoes (1 can, 14 oz, drained): Draining them keeps the filling from turning soupy, which I learned the hard way the first time I made these.
• Italian herbs (1 teaspoon), smoked paprika (1/2 teaspoon), salt and pepper: These seasonings give warmth and complexity without overpowering the dish.
• Olive oil (2 tablespoons): Just enough to build flavor from the onion and garlic without making the filling greasy.

Instructions

Set the stage:

Preheat your oven to 375°F and lightly grease a baking dish that your peppers can nestle into upright—they'll cook more evenly if they're not crowded or tipping over.

Build your flavor base:

Heat olive oil in a skillet over medium heat, then sauté your chopped onion for a couple minutes until it starts to turn translucent and smell sweet. Add the garlic for just 30 seconds more—you want it fragrant, not browned.

Make the filling:

In a large bowl, combine your shredded chicken, cooked rice, the onion and garlic you just made, drained tomatoes, 1 cup of the cheddar, the softened cream cheese, and all your seasonings. Mix everything together until you can't see any streaks of cream cheese and the filling looks cohesive and textured.

Stuff the peppers:

Spoon the filling into each hollow pepper, packing it gently so it holds together without compressing too much. Stand them upright in your prepared baking dish, then scatter the remaining cheddar over the tops like you're giving each one a little crown.

Set up for steam:

Pour about 2-3 tablespoons of water into the bottom of the dish around (not over) the peppers—this creates steam that helps them soften without drying out. Cover loosely with foil; you want the steam to circulate, not get trapped.

Bake and finish:

Bake covered for 25 minutes, then remove the foil and bake another 10 minutes so the cheese gets bubbly and golden on top. The peppers should be tender enough that a fork slides through the flesh easily when you test them.

Rest and serve:

Let them cool for a few minutes—they'll hold together better and be less mouth-shatteringly hot. Serve with something bright, like a green salad, to cut through the richness.

Save to Pinterest

I served this to my sister after she'd had a brutal week at work, and she got quiet for a moment partway through, then just said, 'Thank you'—not for the food itself, but for caring enough to make something that wasn't scrambled eggs or cereal. That's when I understood why this recipe stuck in my rotation.

Why This Becomes a Go-To

There's something deeply satisfying about a recipe that looks like effort but doesn't demand it. The beauty of stuffed peppers is that they're elegant enough for company but simple enough that you can make them on a Tuesday after work without pretending to be someone you're not. Once you've made them once, your hands know the rhythm, and the next time feels even easier.

Customizing Without Overthinking

I've made these a dozen different ways depending on what's in my fridge or what dietary need I'm trying to accommodate. Swap the rice for cauliflower rice if you want to go low-carb, or stir in a handful of fresh spinach if you're trying to sneak vegetables past skeptical eaters. The structure is so forgiving that these additions slide in seamlessly without needing to recalibrate anything else. Even when I've added corn, jalapeños, or switched to Mexican seasoning and pepper jack cheese, the basic technique stays the same.

The Leftovers Question

Honestly, these reheat beautifully—much better than you'd expect for something baked and cheesy. I cover them with foil and warm them at 325°F for about 10 minutes, or I'll pop a single pepper in the microwave for 90 seconds if I'm grabbing lunch at my desk. There's something wonderful about a dish that tastes almost better the next day because the flavors have had time to settle and get to know each other.

• If you're batch-cooking, double the recipe and freeze the unbaked peppers in foil; thaw overnight and bake as directed, adding maybe 5 minutes to the covered time.
• Leftovers stay fresh in the fridge for about 3 days, so this is genuinely a recipe that works for meal prep without tasting like you're eating the same thing on repeat.
• Serve with something acidic on the side—a vinegary salad dressing or a squeeze of fresh lemon completely changes how the richness lands on your palate.

Save to Pinterest

This is the kind of recipe that reminds you why cooking at home matters—not because it's complicated or precious, but because it's reliable and kind and tastes like you actually care. Make it this week.

Recipe FAQs

→ Can I use different types of cheese?

Yes, feel free to substitute cheddar with mozzarella or Monterey Jack for a milder or creamier texture.

→ Is it necessary to cook the chicken beforehand?

Cooked chicken ensures the filling is fully heated and safe to eat after baking. Using rotisserie or leftover chicken works well.

→ What are good variations to the filling?

Try swapping rice for quinoa or cauliflower rice, or add veggies like spinach or corn for extra flavor and texture.

→ How do I make the peppers tender but not soggy?

Baking covered with foil allows the peppers to steam and soften gently; removing foil at the end helps achieve a slight crisp on top.

→ Can this be prepared ahead of time?

Yes, assemble the stuffed peppers in advance and refrigerate. Bake just before serving for best results.